USING CARBON SCORING TO STEER ADVERTISING TOWARDS MORE SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTS

11. 12. 2025

FranceTV Publicité has partnered with independent consultancy Carbone 4 to measure the climate compatibility of advertised products and, from 2026, to encourage higher-scoring products with preferential airtime across its ecosystem. This approach treats climate-compatible advertising as a lever sales houses can actively control, rather than a passive constraint. The following sections highlight seven points sales houses can focus on if they wish to replicate or adapt the model.

Replace media-only CO₂ metrics with neutral A–F product scoring

The partnership rests on two principles: working with a neutral third party that has no commercial links with advertisers, and using a methodology that is scientific, transparent and aligned with the Paris Agreement.

Carbone 4 adapts its “compatibility with the Paris Agreement” methodology to evaluate the carbon performance of products promoted in spots, looking primarily at usage and alignment with a low-carbon trajectory rather than only at the emissions of the campaign itself.

Products are classified on a simple A–F scale, similar in spirit to front‑of‑pack nutrition labels such as the Nutri‑Score used in some European countries, but applied to carbon performance. The classification is assigned to individual models or product lines rather than to brands in general, and is designed to be intelligible to marketers and regulators.

Focus on high-impact sectors and hard-wire scoring into trading rules

FranceTV Publicité and Carbone 4 focus first on three high-impact advertiser sectors: mobility, food and energy, which together account for a large share of French households’ carbon footprint.

By mid-2025, more than 200 mobility and transport campaigns had already been analysed to establish a usable reference base. Food and energy campaigns are scheduled to follow in stages, with sector-specific criteria refined as evidence accumulates.

The scoring sits within a broader climate roadmap. FranceTV Publicité’s own emissions-reduction targets have been validated by the Science Based Targets initiative, with a commitment to reduce scope 1–3 emissions by 42% by 2030 and a longer-term programme that integrates carbon, attention and audience metrics into its offer.

From January 2026, the Carbone 4 reference enters the trading rules: campaigns that promote mobility products rated A, B or C will benefit from preferential positions (for example, first or last in break) on TV and digital, giving more visibility to products compatible with a decarbonisation pathway while not formally excluding other campaigns.

This partnership with Carbone 4 is an important milestone in our sustainability journey. By joining forces with a leading player, well known for its expertise in low-carbon strategy, we are choosing to evaluate the impact of the advertising campaigns we broadcast. It is a practical solution that will help support our partners in their own green transitions, in accordance with the goals of the Paris Agreement.

This initiative reflects our ambitions of being a driver of change within the sector, by using advertising to help reduce our carbon footprint—for companies and citizens alike. We believe in virtuous, responsible advertising that reflects society’s expectations.

By raising awareness among a large audience, advertising can also help to encourage the French public to adopt more sustainable behaviours. It is a real step towards striking the right balance between performance, sustainability, and usefulness.

Marianne Siproudhis
CEO, France TV Publicité

Clarify who does what between sales house and independent expert

Carbone 4 designs the method, defines the sector frameworks and calculates the scores, bringing external expertise and independence as a specialist in low-carbon strategies.

FranceTV Publicité commissions the work, opens its catalogue of campaigns as a testbed and integrates the resulting A–F labels into its climate strategy and CGV 2026 framework.

Internally, RSE and strategic planning functions are combined so that climate considerations are embedded in offer design rather than treated as a separate CSR add-on. This internal organisation helps translate external expertise into concrete sales-house products.

See how car and travel brands reshape planning with A–F scores

A mobility advertiser may have several product lines scored differently: for example, small electric models rated A or B, hybrids around C, and larger internal-combustion models scoring lower.

Under the CGV 2026 rules, only campaigns that put forward models rated A–C qualify for free preferential positions in breaks. This pushes the advertiser to decide which models to feature in creative, and how to sequence campaigns over time.

In practice, this can mean shifting the focus of TV copy and tag-ons towards higher-scoring models, or adjusting media pressure between ranges as their scores evolve. The same A–F classification can be reused in internal reporting and in conversations with regulators, since the scoring comes from an independent, Paris-aligned methodology rather than from the advertiser or the sales house alone.

Advertising’s primary goal is to guide the behaviours of consumers, by persuading them to buy specific products or services. When there is less advertising for low-carbon products, consumers are more likely to be influenced by messages that go against efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

By partnering with us to evaluate how well their broadcast messages align with the country’s low-carbon goals, FranceTV Publicité is paving the way for broader industry-wide discussions on how advertising can evolve in a world undergoing transition. We are delighted to have contributed to this initiative, which we hope will lead to useful changes in practice.

Jean-Marc Jancovici
Partner, Carbone 4

Tie the climate scores directly to concrete advantages

Most existing tools in media focus on the footprint of the campaign itself (production, distribution and impressions). Here, the central object is the product advertised: its lifecycle emissions and its compatibility with a national decarbonisation pathway.

For sales houses, the innovation is not just the presence of a carbon indicator, but the link between scoring and higher visibility: higher-scoring product campaigns receive better positions for the same investment. The mechanism is framed as favouring compatible products rather than penalising others, which may make it easier to deploy in mixed portfolios.

The choice of an external climate expert also addresses a credibility gap. It allows the sales house to present the scoring as independent and robust in trade and public discussions, and to position it as a contribution to a broader sector reflection on how advertising aligns with decarbonisation.

Build a climate-compatible portfolio that fits your wider strategy

Short term, FranceTV Publicité plans to extend the Carbone 4 scoring from mobility to food and energy as sufficient campaigns are analysed, and to refine how preferential treatment is operationalised in daily trading and planning tools.

Medium term, the company has signalled an intention to share its protocol and insights more widely within the industry, with the objective of contributing to a more self-regulating, transparent and climate-compatible advertising ecosystem.

For other sales houses, the replicable elements are clear: select an independent climate partner; build a simple, intelligible product-level scoring focused on high-impact sectors; connect that scoring to higher visibility (for example, preferred slots); and integrate the approach into a broader climate strategy that also covers the sales house’s own operational emissions and RSE positioning.

Source: egta.com